Pros
Intriguing premise.
Vitale might be one of the best characters of all time.
easily an 8-9/10 game for the 3 main routes.
The plot twists are actually well done.
the characters are multidimensional and complex. Each character has a very different take on love and what it means to them.
theres just enough mystery around the characters left, even after everything has been unlocked, that youre left wondering without the game feeling incomplete (the fates really have it out for Rose). Some routes are definitely worth replaying with later game knowledge.
The whole queer allegory aspect of the theme is prominent without being on the nose.

Neutral
This is, of course, a game with a fixed main character. You might need a bit to get into the game, since you wont feel attached to characters or the named protagonist in the beginning, but get thrown right into their struggles.
The game has well marked POV changes, though Vitale always leaves me wondering if his more unhinged thoughts are hidden from us.

Cons
Yeah, its all minor art polish. The main character is drawn inconsistently (proportions, face shape, and height to other characters), which can be a bit distracting. It happens to a degree where the reader has to wonder if its partly intentional and supposed to communicate how other characters see Rose.

The landladys (grandmas) sprite needs polish in how her wrinkles are drawn.

???
The hidden routes execution choices. Great if you wanted to solidify your lore theories, but I personally wish the game committed to one undertone of several instead of having it be a bit of everything: serious, crackship, toxic rebound, actual relationship. I feel like Im in a rollercoaster and its all Eros fault. Where have I heard that before?

Haven't played for too long yet, but it got me hooked onto the story so bad I stopped voice acting it, which is definitely an accomplishment! Art is beautiful, Icardi is beautiful, Icardi is amazing, I REALLY love Icardi... Didn't have high expectations, especially because bl games tend to just be okay nowadays, but it's good and I recommend buying it! I love you Icardi

Overall, I really enjoyed this visual novel and I recommend checking it out - while initially I was a bit lost about being thrown right into the action without having more explanations for the overall lore/other things that our character was supposed to know, I grew accustomed to the game's less 'hand-hold'-y style. I really liked the story and the fact that each romance interest had his own unique route - so 'introduction' was the only common part between all them.

The setting is really interesting, and I also really loved how the game was drawn. Melrose was also a really entertaining and relatable main character, I loved his defined personality and struggles. Though I wish there was a bit more interactivity to it between the major story beats, even if we had to roleplay within the bounds of a predefined personality.

Dr. Love was the first one I went after - and he remained my favorite throughout the game. While I liked both Icardi's and Vitali's route, I found Icardi's harmony route to be kind of lacking, as it was the only route where we didn't get to see more of the inner workings of the Thespiae in the 'concluding' chapters, and it felt kind of unsatisfactory that the conflict with the cupids/other gods just went away without much explanation?.. .

On the technical side, there was one major problem - this game doesn't have a proper cloud saving system, so since I played the game on 2 different devices while travelling, I had to manually sync up with RenPy's servers to transfer my save files.